process ile Etiketlenmiş Yazılar
The Difference between ART and DESIGN
admin tarafından, Art and Design kategorisi altında, 02/04/2009 tarihinde gönderildi
These terms are frequently mixed up. Not by what their meanings are but by what they signify. Of course a design doesn’t necessarily have to be a work of art, however it can display some form of art. Again can art contain some form of design? To understand where both terms stand in relevance to each other we must know what each term really means.
What is Art?
According to wikipedia:
“Art is the process or product of deliberately arranging elements in a way that appeals to the senses or emotions. It encompasses a diverse range of human activities, creations, and modes of expression, including music and literature. The meaning of art is explored in a branch of philosophy known as Aesthetics.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art
What we understand from this definition is that Art is either a process or a product of a composition that appeals to our senses. The keywords we can grab from this paragraph that defines Art are “process, product, composition, senses, emotions”
The relevant definition for Art from wiktionary is:
“The conscious production or arrangement of sounds, colours, forms, movements, or other elements in a manner that affects the sense of beauty, specifically the production of the beautiful in a graphic or plastic medium. ” or
“A re-creation of reality according to the artist’s metaphysical value-judgements. “
http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/art
The keywords we get from these definitions are “elements of sound, colours, forms, movements etc., sense of beauty, production, and graphic/plastic medium, creation, reality, artist, metaphysical “.
Another description from Merriam Webster is:
“The conscious use of skill and creative imagination especially in the production of aesthetic objects ; also : works so produced”
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/art[2]
Here we have a different set of keywords, such as “conscious, imagination, works produced, aesthetic objects”.
If we combine the keywords from these definitions we can get a statement like: “Art is a concious process derived from the creative imagination of producing a product of aesthetic value that appeals to the senses or emotions.”
Now why did we do this? We want a definition of Art that is not just according to one source. We want to now what Art means in general. And now we know that it is a process or the product of an object which appeals to the senses and it can be in any plastic or graphic form. But we don’t know if there is anything else Art can do, other than appeal to the senses or emotions.
Now after reading these definitions of Art let’s see have a look at what Design is.
What is Design?
You can read a more detailed article, “What is design?” on another post of mine. But for this argument lets research some definitions from online sources.
According to wikipedia
“As a noun, “a design” is used for either the final (solution) plan (e.g. proposal, drawing, model, description) or the result of implementing that plan in the form of the final product of a design process“
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design
Merriam Webster defines Design as:
“a: An underlying scheme that governs functioning, developing, or unfolding : pattern , motif <the general design of the epic> b: a plan or protocol for carrying out or accomplishing something (as a scientific experiment) ; also : the process of preparing this”
“The arrangement of elements or details in a product or work of art”
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/design[2]
Here we see that design be a little bit more technical. According to the definitions Design is more about how you get to the final product, it is the route by which you choose to take. And you can also say it is the final product of the process as a noun. It has nothing to do with appealing to the emotions, but it can please us if it takes us to the final product with ease. I think that we can say the answer of the question “What is Design?” is “The process chosen to produce a product?” and “the product itself”.
Is Design a kind of art?
If design is a process leading to a product and art is a form of aesthetics then we can state that Design is a product with a touch of artistic value. According to Vitruvius, a roman architect, engineer and writer (born c. 80–70 BC, died after c. 15 BC) Design is when form (venustas=beauty) meets function (veritas=truth). We can also say that when we find an aesthetic side to technology we can say it is an aesthetic, pretty, beautiful design.
Can Art be designed?
Now we can ask the last question “Can we design an art object?” Well I think the answer is quite obvious. Why can’t we? Isn’t an art object a product in the end? And don’t artists plan the process to get to the final product? However It wouldn’t be fair to say that art is design as a product since we need a function other than appealing to the senses and emotions. So as a result, we can say that art can be designed but we don’t end up with a design as a product, but a work of art.
For further reading, you can look up this subject following the links below:
http://www.unc.edu/~jbrady/Essays/Art_Design.html
http://jonathanbaldwin.blogspot.com/2004/05/graphic-design-is-not-art.html
http://www.underconsideration.com/speakup/archives/001362.html
http://www.ablestable.com/resources/library/thecolumn/2004/019.htm
http://everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=931484
http://www.artbistro.com/topics/7615-the-differences-between-art-and-design/posts
Related Reading:
What is Design?
admin tarafından, Art and Design kategorisi altında, 26/03/2009 tarihinde gönderildi
This post is for beginners who have newly entered the world of design. I hope it helps give you insight about the life ahead of you.
Nowadays wherever we turn our eyes we see expressions like “Design of the year”, “Designer furniture”, “Designer’s handbook”, “Design of this…”, Designer’s that…”, etc.
What is Design?
This question is one of those questions that when you get a glimpse of an answer it can change your life forever.
Actually I have no recollection of any question as powerful as this one, except for the mighty question “is there God?”, which as a question can keep your mind puzzled all your life. You may never get an answer at all. you may give up asking and just go on with your life.
However, if you are in a profession related to design, you need to know the answer of this question. How can you produce something that you don’t have an explanation for? how can you earn your living off design if you don’t know what it means? It is one of those things that you can’t hold on to with your bare hands but you get an insight of. So I ask again:
What is Design?…
I asked this question over and over again in my university freshman year. The instructors of Basic Design 101 told us many things to explain this phenominal question, such as;
“Design is like a recipe you must have a specific amount of the right ingredients to make a pot of soup”; or,
“A good design is a sum of the components, but the whole of the design is much more than the sum of the individual components. The components are arranged so as to create the quality of the whole.” The arrangement of the components gain significance in this explanation.
How are the components to be arranged? With a specific order! This is when we learn about order… Then oops… before I understand what design is, I must learn what order is.
So I asked what is order?…
I mean I know what it is in general terms, but how does it take place in a design? If I am going to produce a design, how do I use order?
The instructors said you have to put together a set of rules to define and implement your design. Then, for which reason I did not know, I started to make up some rules to get to a design I had in my mind. Somehow I thought it was stupid, the process of making up rules to get to a final design, a design I already had a picture of in mind.
The process wasn’t complete for me. I had to complete a task, a task expected of me that should be a good design, but how? How to get there? I had to create a set of rules to complete the design. But then came another question beginning with how… How was I to set the rules of my order that put the components together to achieve a whole that was of a greater quality than the sum of its components?
This line of questions grew longer and longer, then after many exercises and tasks, I had begun to look at everything with a critical eye. Whatever came upon my way I was always thinking about whether it served its purpose as a design. Then one day…
Since I was continuously observing everything around me. I realised that everything had a purpose. The tv was there in that particular shape for me to watch it, the table was such a table for a reason, my car was in that shape to serve more efficiently, even the painting on the wall was there to remind me of something. Every object was a necessity, and seeing these in that way changed my approach to every step I took. It occurred to me that designing was a lifestyle, a way of looking at things, an attitude towards life.
“Design” (as a noun) had to have a purpose. And “designing” (as a verb) was a method of solving a specific problem within a given environment to serve a purpose.
So I was enlightened. Design seemed more like a mathematical formula than an abstract entity.
It is clear now. Design is a process where you start from scratch and you end up with a product, which serves a purpose or set of purposes:
1. Define the problem: What is the task at hand?
2. Case study: Analysis of any given data.
3. Research: Investigation of alternative solutions. Develop your set of rules.
4. Decision Making: Deciding on which solution is best. Decide on an order for your design.
5. Development: Producing principal design solution. You get your preliminary design approved.
6. Implementation: Constructing the design.
7. Evaluation: Completion of project and user criticism.
Maybe it seems very technical but with a touch of aesthetical value, when you apply such a process to the design task at hand you will find that your design is much more practical, efficient, appreciated and successful.
And when you do get it, you will find that you apply it to every part of your life, even to your personal problems.
Design is nothing but a solution to a problem. When you feel that the process is a part of you then you know that you are a Designer.








Latest comments